Why generative AI doesn’t belong in crafting/handmade spaces
We’re going to use a plot point in Schitt’s Creek for this example... You may be familiar with it!
A photograph of Alexis Rose saying "Ew, David no!"
Why generative AI doesn’t belong in crafting/handmade spaces
Later in the television series Schitt’s Creek (S5 Ep10), main character David Rose decides to open an apothecary called “Rose Apothecary.”
(Photo of David Rose)
He hand curates and selects handmade, high quality items made by small business owners he knows he can trust.
(Photo of Rose Apothecary building)
It is an adorable addition to an otherwise run-down town, and it does well! High quality, handmade items sell at a premium
Why generative AI doesn’t belong in crafting/handmade spaces
During a local small business event in town in which he is representing Rose Apothecary, he notices a former business partner who has set up a table not far from him.
(Photo of David and Stevie at the event)
She and her business partner, who looks suspiciously like David himself, are selling “hand curated, hand made” lotions, creams, etc, just like Rose Apothecary.
(Photo of Antonio and Wendy at the event)
However, they are selling them much, much cheaper, undercutting David. It later turns out that they are purchasing cheap manufactured goods and relabeling them to make them seem hand crafted/small batch.
Why generative AI doesn’t belong in crafting/handmade spaces
This is exactly what generative AI, whether used in whole or part does when placed in a handmade space.
It devalues artisans who have spent a lot of time, money, and effort making something good by creating a “rip-off” product that sells for cheaper.
Even if you are “only” using generative AI for labels or logos, even having just that reduces trust in all of the vendors around you for anyone who has a keen eye to AI generated assets. This destabilizes trust in the entire collective of artisans, because if one vendor is getting away with using gen AI, then who else is?
Today I'm making a presentation and this is part of it