Advertisement · 728 × 90

Posts by Paul L. Franco

Every minute I spend teaching Russell's analysis of descriptions is a minute I'm not strategizing about how to leverage AI-powered solutions to flip classrooms and empower students to enter the modern workforce with the agile skills our local business partners and their stakeholders value.

4 days ago 11 0 2 0

Born to be dean, cursed to be rank-and-file faculty.

4 days ago 4 0 1 1
These, of course, are intuitions; I do not have an argument for these conclusions. Nevertheless, the burden of proof is surely on the other side

These, of course, are intuitions; I do not have an argument for these conclusions. Nevertheless, the burden of proof is surely on the other side

The characteristic argumentative rigor of analytic philosophy.

4 days ago 6 1 0 1

Never once have I read G.E. Moore's list of facts he knows with certainty and wondered how to interpret the common sense view of the world.

1 week ago 2 0 0 0

It's sort of wild to me that Continental Philosophy has never produced anything as perspicuous as Bertrand Russell's famously clear Gray's Elegy argument in "On Denoting."

1 week ago 4 1 1 0

Given the peer review crisis, I wouldn't be surprised if it takes another 2,000 years for this to get published.

1 week ago 2 0 1 0

Retvrn to when naturalism meant telling plausible-sounding stories about how people might learn language by having their surfaces irritated.

2 weeks ago 2 0 0 0
Leibniz Translations

I'm not sure I totally understand Leibniz's plan for crossing a river in view of an enemy army aside from the recommendation to make a cannon-proof boat.

www.leibniz-translations.com/river

3 weeks ago 3 0 0 0

If I knew what I know now in graduate school I wouldn't have audited Kant's first Critique like three times and would've replaced at least one of those with a class about making Canvas modules because my job has way less first Critique and way more making Canvas modules than I could've ever guessed.

3 weeks ago 6 1 0 0

Long time favorite.

theonion.com/im-like-a-ch...

3 weeks ago 2 0 0 0
Advertisement

Shortsighted. Eliminate Classics and future creators won't learn about Socrates, one of the West's first influencers--even if he quite famously didn't create content himself--and also someone who, through the invention of the Socratic method, has a lot to say about prompt engineering.

4 weeks ago 5 0 0 0

March Madness and Looping Effects: How Bracketology Made the Modern NCAA Fan

1 month ago 0 0 0 0
unintelligible (as in many anthropological and theological
examples where the criteria of identity, for example, o f men
with birds, three persons in one, etc., do not answer to our
criteria), but where we may eventually become convinced
that these locutions are part of a language because we are able
to extend our understanding and our language in unpredict-
able ways to give intelligibility. In such cases we have no
evidence that there are rules for such extensions of under-
standing— they certainly do not always conform in obvious
ways to the application of propositional logic. For example,
some alien locutions come to be understood eventually as
metaphors, comparable with our non-propositional use of
l a n g u a g e in poetic contexts. It is therefore never safe to claim
that we have found necessary truths to demarcate language as
such. To do so is to define the limits of language a priori in
ways that can turn out arbitrary and unilluminating.

unintelligible (as in many anthropological and theological examples where the criteria of identity, for example, o f men with birds, three persons in one, etc., do not answer to our criteria), but where we may eventually become convinced that these locutions are part of a language because we are able to extend our understanding and our language in unpredict- able ways to give intelligibility. In such cases we have no evidence that there are rules for such extensions of under- standing— they certainly do not always conform in obvious ways to the application of propositional logic. For example, some alien locutions come to be understood eventually as metaphors, comparable with our non-propositional use of l a n g u a g e in poetic contexts. It is therefore never safe to claim that we have found necessary truths to demarcate language as such. To do so is to define the limits of language a priori in ways that can turn out arbitrary and unilluminating.

Mary Hesse came up with the plot to TNG's Darmok a full decade before it aired.

1 month ago 0 0 0 0
To this argument it may be, and has been, objected that the "vulgar"
usage of the pair 'up-down' was never supposed to be so general as to
be applicable to the universe as a whole. This may be the case (although
I do not see any reason for assuming that "ordinary" people are so very
cautious as to apply the pair to the surface of the earth only; all the
passages referred to in the above quotations contradict this assumption
and so does the fact that at all times real ordinary people-and not only
their Oxford substitutes-were very much interested in celestial phe-
nomena 104 ) . However, even such a restriction would not invalidate our
argument. It would rather show that the pair was used for singling out
an absolute direction near the surface of the earth and that it did not
assume such a direction to exist throughout the universe. It is clear that
even this modest position is incompatible with the ideas implicit in the
Newtonian point of view, which does not allow for local anisotropies
either.

To this argument it may be, and has been, objected that the "vulgar" usage of the pair 'up-down' was never supposed to be so general as to be applicable to the universe as a whole. This may be the case (although I do not see any reason for assuming that "ordinary" people are so very cautious as to apply the pair to the surface of the earth only; all the passages referred to in the above quotations contradict this assumption and so does the fact that at all times real ordinary people-and not only their Oxford substitutes-were very much interested in celestial phe- nomena 104 ) . However, even such a restriction would not invalidate our argument. It would rather show that the pair was used for singling out an absolute direction near the surface of the earth and that it did not assume such a direction to exist throughout the universe. It is clear that even this modest position is incompatible with the ideas implicit in the Newtonian point of view, which does not allow for local anisotropies either.

"The reason why Oxford philosophers so rarely discuss the influence of astronomy upon everyday languages may perhaps be found in the weather of their favorite discussion place. However, this unfortunately does not explain their ignorance in physics, theology, mythology, biology, and even linguistics."

"The reason why Oxford philosophers so rarely discuss the influence of astronomy upon everyday languages may perhaps be found in the weather of their favorite discussion place. However, this unfortunately does not explain their ignorance in physics, theology, mythology, biology, and even linguistics."

See also Feyerabend (1962, 86) on the Oxonians: "The reason why Oxford philosophers so rarely discuss the influence of astronomy upon everyday languages may perhaps be found in the weather of their favorite discussion place. However, this...does not explain their ignorance in [everything else]."

1 month ago 1 0 0 0
"It comes, first, from the desire to see "the whole correspond to its parts with wonderful simplicity" (341), as already expressed by Copernicus himself. ® It comes from the "typically metaphysical urge" for unity of understanding and of conceptual presentation. ∞ And, secondly, the motive for a change is connected with the intention to make room for the motion of the earth which Galileo has accepted and is not prepared to give up."

"It comes, first, from the desire to see "the whole correspond to its parts with wonderful simplicity" (341), as already expressed by Copernicus himself. ® It comes from the "typically metaphysical urge" for unity of understanding and of conceptual presentation. ∞ And, secondly, the motive for a change is connected with the intention to make room for the motion of the earth which Galileo has accepted and is not prepared to give up."

Cf. with this the still existing and even increasing resistance against universal understanding as it can be found in Professor Austin's "philosophy" (Sense and Sensibilia, remarks on Thales). What has advanced and even created science is today ridiculed and pushed aside by men (and women) who have barely advanced beyond the multiplication table."

Cf. with this the still existing and even increasing resistance against universal understanding as it can be found in Professor Austin's "philosophy" (Sense and Sensibilia, remarks on Thales). What has advanced and even created science is today ridiculed and pushed aside by men (and women) who have barely advanced beyond the multiplication table."

Feyerabend on Austin's "philosophy" (scare quotes his), with a quip seemingly about the extent of Austin's scientific knowledge ("barely advanced beyond the multiplication table"), in the context of a discussion of Galileo, conceptual change, and experience.

archive.org/details/natu...

1 month ago 4 0 1 0
Preview
QUANATA AND REALITY A SYMPOSIUM : DAVID BOHM : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

"Quanta and Reality" with some 1961 BBC lectures introduced by Stephen Toulmin, and featuring Mary Hesse on models and N.R. Hanson commenting.

archive.org/details/quan...

1 month ago 0 0 0 0

I found this chart aspirational; I too hope to live to 120 even if it means my influence wanes a bit.

1 month ago 6 3 1 0
A can of Yinz Jawn Pennsylvania lager. Yellow and red styled to look like a can of Pennsylvania Dutch birch beer.

A can of Yinz Jawn Pennsylvania lager. Yellow and red styled to look like a can of Pennsylvania Dutch birch beer.

Yinz Jawn PA lager. With shared ties to the Keystone State, Triceratops (Rob, aka Yinz) and Lucky Envelope (Barry, aka Jawn) are excited to bring you a collaboration inspired by our formative Lager brewed by America's oldest brewery. The Yinz Jawn Lager is our take on the American Amber Lager, brewed with Weyermann malt, corn, and hopped with German Mittelfruh and Saphir as a nod to our Pennsylvania Dutch roots. Yinz thirsty? Grab some of this jawn.

Yinz Jawn PA lager. With shared ties to the Keystone State, Triceratops (Rob, aka Yinz) and Lucky Envelope (Barry, aka Jawn) are excited to bring you a collaboration inspired by our formative Lager brewed by America's oldest brewery. The Yinz Jawn Lager is our take on the American Amber Lager, brewed with Weyermann malt, corn, and hopped with German Mittelfruh and Saphir as a nod to our Pennsylvania Dutch roots. Yinz thirsty? Grab some of this jawn.

I guess some Pacific Northwest breweries are brewing Lager now.

1 month ago 1 0 0 0

"Neglected Alternative" sounds more like the title of an album compilation of lesser-known early 90s PNW bands rather than the metaphysical thesis that space and time are both forms of intuition and properties of things-in-themselves.

1 month ago 2 0 1 0
Advertisement
You talked about a war going on in Cambridge between historians and philosophers of science, but the
sixties at Harvard seems that was also a place of confrontations… Did you feel that way when you were
studying there in those years?
Not at Harvard, in part because in a sense the war had already concluded. I took courses from
Hillary Putnam and Israel Scheffler. The philosophers did not speak with the historians of scien-
ce, and the historians of science did not speak with the philosophers. At Cambridge they were
still together in one Department, and the colloquium was a battlefield. Particularly among the
historians of Medicine, Robert Young and Karl Figlio, a Marxist approach was dominant, which
was anathema to the philosophers. That was the early seventies, when the battle lines were poli-
tical, and to some extent I think also national. Both Karl Figlio and Bob Young, that made their
careers in Cambridge, were Americans. Among the philosophers, Mary Hesse was British and
Gerd Buchdahl was German. It was in part a clash of different national, intellectual traditions
and formations. I certainly never regretted the work that I did with Mary Hesse nor what I
learned about Kant and Goethe’s Naturphilosophie from Gerd Buchdahl,. Howeverr, it was quite
clear that a reconciliation among the warring parties was not in the offing, and for the graduate
students who were there at the time it was like being in the midst of divorcing parents: you had
to declare which side you were on. It was at that point that I decided that I was not going to
continue my PhD at Cambridge

You talked about a war going on in Cambridge between historians and philosophers of science, but the sixties at Harvard seems that was also a place of confrontations… Did you feel that way when you were studying there in those years? Not at Harvard, in part because in a sense the war had already concluded. I took courses from Hillary Putnam and Israel Scheffler. The philosophers did not speak with the historians of scien- ce, and the historians of science did not speak with the philosophers. At Cambridge they were still together in one Department, and the colloquium was a battlefield. Particularly among the historians of Medicine, Robert Young and Karl Figlio, a Marxist approach was dominant, which was anathema to the philosophers. That was the early seventies, when the battle lines were poli- tical, and to some extent I think also national. Both Karl Figlio and Bob Young, that made their careers in Cambridge, were Americans. Among the philosophers, Mary Hesse was British and Gerd Buchdahl was German. It was in part a clash of different national, intellectual traditions and formations. I certainly never regretted the work that I did with Mary Hesse nor what I learned about Kant and Goethe’s Naturphilosophie from Gerd Buchdahl,. Howeverr, it was quite clear that a reconciliation among the warring parties was not in the offing, and for the graduate students who were there at the time it was like being in the midst of divorcing parents: you had to declare which side you were on. It was at that point that I decided that I was not going to continue my PhD at Cambridge

Lorraine Daston on historians and philosophers of science at Harvard and Cambridge (the university) in the 1970s.

ojs.fhce.edu.uy/index.php/co...

1 month ago 3 0 0 0

Socrates's h-index was 0.

1 month ago 5 1 2 0

Find the person in your department who is the commissioner of a yearly fantasy league and you will have someone who is ready for an internal leadership role. And if they are commissioner of a dynasty league, they are ready to be your university's next president.

1 month ago 1 0 0 0
Preview
Silent Flight An ideal reader and honest seeker dives into the world of Zhuangzi, the great Chinese philosopher.

A classic of world philosophy, the Zhuangzi revolutionized ethics and ontology forever with its Dao.

Now, in our latest issue, Rose Novick brings this masterpiece to a new generation of English readers with her magisterial translation & commentary.

strangematters.coop/rose-novick-...

1 month ago 48 18 2 1

I can't even recognize that time slice of me who thought he might have publishable professional opinions about Kant any more.

1 month ago 2 0 0 0
Kant by Paul Guyer and Kant and the claims of knowledge also by Paul Guyer open on my desk with a blue bandana next to it, which I suppose would be my old Kantian colors.

Kant by Paul Guyer and Kant and the claims of knowledge also by Paul Guyer open on my desk with a blue bandana next to it, which I suppose would be my old Kantian colors.

Bugs Bunny with a gun with a caption: "Lord forgive me but its time to go back to tha old me."

Bugs Bunny with a gun with a caption: "Lord forgive me but its time to go back to tha old me."

It's that part of the term in Modern Philosophy.

1 month ago 3 0 1 0

We're excited to announce the Spring 2026 PSA office hours! Come learn, ask questions, and connect with leading voices in philosophy of science!

Details in the 🧵
Registration at this link: www.philsci.org/psa_...

1 month ago 12 12 1 3
Advertisement

Is Mina Kimes the first Kantian to win an Emmy?

1 month ago 2 0 0 0
Post image

The book cover is out! This project consumed much of my brain for several years, and I learned a ton working on it.

1 month ago 2 1 0 0

As a pedestrian, there's nothing more delightful than crossing a street diagonally at an all-way walk.

1 month ago 1 0 0 0
A diagram. A tree to the right affects the senses of a person to the left giving rise to a thought bubble with two trees in it. Underneath a dashed line is a head using reason to come up with concepts that match the world.

A diagram. A tree to the right affects the senses of a person to the left giving rise to a thought bubble with two trees in it. Underneath a dashed line is a head using reason to come up with concepts that match the world.

Space and underneath are lots of s1s and then a square inside a circle inside a larger circle.

Space and underneath are lots of s1s and then a square inside a circle inside a larger circle.

Latest achievements in whiteboard work.

1 month ago 4 0 1 0