Advertisement · 728 × 90

Posts by David H. Gans

Preview
The Inside Story of Five Days That Remade the Supreme Court

"Even as they debated the Obama plan’s possible burden on the power industry, in the entire chain of correspondence obtained by The Times, not a single justice … mentioned the dangers of a warming planet as one of the possible harms the court should consider.” www.nytimes.com/2026/04/18/u...

3 days ago 556 198 16 22

Read that again. This Louisiana bill forces homeless people to choose between jail and "treatment"—and if they can't pay for the latter, they will be forced to perform unpaid labor.

The historical precedents are clear: convict leasing, Black Codes, debtor's prison.

5 days ago 1898 1143 62 68
Preview
David Gans on the History of the Reconstruction Amendments, and the Connection to Current Supreme Court Cases, including Callais #ELB Gans in Slate: In the next few months, the Supreme Court will issue a spate of potentially landmark rulings on the meaning of the Reconstruction Amendments. In Louisiana v. Callais, currently the earl...

@davidhgans.bsky.social's latest article in @slate.com discussing the Black Conventions after the Civil War was featured on the Election Law Blog. Read more: electionlawblog.org?p=155448

5 days ago 1 1 0 0

In advance of more SCT opinions tomorrow, remember this: "the Supreme Court cannot do justice to the Reconstruction Amendments without reckoning with the ways Black Americans shaped these transformational amendments and the principles of freedom, equality, and multiracial democracy they guarantee."

5 days ago 0 0 0 0
Preview
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson slams Supreme Court’s emergency docket actions Jackson faulted her fellow justices for often forcing the public and lower-court judges to rely on “scratch-paper musings."

NEW: Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson unloads on #SCOTUS handling of emergency/'shadow' docket, saying it often seems 'utterly irrational' & can lead to 'zombie' proceedings. KBJ rejects Kavanaugh's 'interim docket' label, calls for focus on real-world harms
www.politico.com/news/2026/04...

6 days ago 338 101 6 12
Preview
David Gans on the History of the Reconstruction Amendments, and the Connection to Current Supreme Court Cases, including Callais #ELB Gans in Slate: In the next few months, the Supreme Court will issue a spate of potentially landmark rulings on the meaning of the Reconstruction Amendments. In Louisiana v. Callais, currently the earl...

David Gans on the History of the Reconstruction Amendments, and the Connection to Current Supreme Court Cases, including Callais electionlawblog.org?p=155448

6 days ago 17 6 0 0
Preview
The Supreme Court Has a Chance to Revolutionize Its Approach to the Law In the next few months, the Supreme Court will issue a spate of potentially landmark rulings on the meaning of the Reconstruction Amendments.

When #SCOTUS discusses the text and history of the Reconstruction Amendments, it generally omits the critical role Black Americans played in their liberation struggle and how their activism informed the Constitution. Read more from @davidhgans.bsky.social:
slate.com/news-and-pol...

6 days ago 2 2 0 0
Forgotten Framers: Black Conventions and the Second Founding This Article tells the forgotten story of the Black Conventions of the Reconstruction era, examining convenings of Black Americans across the nation during the

Interested in learning more about Black Conventions during Reconstruction? Check out my forthcoming @stanlrev.bsky.social article that argues that engaging with the Black Conventions is critical to a proper understanding of the Reconstruction Amendments: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers....

6 days ago 6 4 0 0
Preview
The Supreme Court Has a Chance to Revolutionize Its Approach to the Law In the next few months, the Supreme Court will issue a spate of potentially landmark rulings on the meaning of the Reconstruction Amendments.

My latest @slate.com tells the story of the Black Convention movement during Reconstruction & how it shaped the Reconstruction Amendments. With three huge 14A cases awaiting decision, it's time to heed Justice Jackson's call for a more inclusive history. slate.com/news-and-pol...

6 days ago 9 4 1 1
Preview
13th Annual Home Stretch at the Supreme Court | Constitutional Accountability Center Our panel of distinguished experts will discuss some of the most significant cases from this Supreme Court Term and look ahead to major rulings and issues on the horizon. From battles over tariffs, bi...

Register now for CAC's annual Home Stretch event, featuring remarks from @elizabethwydra.bsky.social and an all-star panel of legal experts, moderated by @chrisgeidner.bsky.social. Join the conversation as we unpack the biggest issues at #SCOTUS this term: www.theusconstitution.org/events/13th-...

1 week ago 1 1 0 0
Advertisement

Looking forward to reading!

1 week ago 1 0 0 0

Congrats Rick!

1 week ago 1 0 0 0
Post image

Until 2023, this is how it was commemorated. This is why monuments matter. www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/...

1 week ago 391 78 6 2

If you don’t know about this, you need to read up. It’s the single bloodiest massacre in the history of Reconstruction, and it was perpetrated to overthrow the results of an election. It was emblematic of the sabotage of Reconstruction. And SCOTUS nullified the prosecution of those responsible.

1 week ago 1796 768 14 18
Preview
A Reflection On the 150th Anniversary of the Dedication of Freedmen's Memorial in Washington, DC. Today the National Park Service is commemorating the 150th anniversary of the dedication of the Freedmen’s Memorial in Washington, DC.

Wish I could be in DC today. #CivilWarMemory open.substack.com/pub/kevinmle...

1 week ago 49 10 1 2

Congrats Evan! Can’t wait to read it.

1 week ago 1 0 0 0

Congrats Tanner!

1 week ago 1 0 0 0
Preview
13th Annual Home Stretch at the Supreme Court | Constitutional Accountability Center Our panel of distinguished experts will discuss some of the most significant cases from this Supreme Court Term and look ahead to major rulings and issues on the horizon. From battles over tariffs, bi...

Very much looking forward to moderating this @myconstitution.bsky.social panel with these superstars at the end of this month. Sign up now! www.theusconstitution.org/events/13th-...

1 week ago 69 17 2 0
Advertisement
Preview
13th Annual Home Stretch at the Supreme Court | Constitutional Accountability Center Our panel of distinguished experts will discuss some of the most significant cases from this Supreme Court Term and look ahead to major rulings and issues on the horizon. From battles over tariffs, bi...

Register now for CAC's annual Home Stretch event, featuring remarks from @elizabethwydra.bsky.social and an all-star panel of legal experts, moderated by @chrisgeidner.bsky.social. Join the conversation as we unpack the biggest issues at #SCOTUS this term: www.theusconstitution.org/events/13th-...

2 weeks ago 2 2 0 0
Preview
California v. Trump | Constitutional Accountability Center

Before oral argument in the First Circuit tomorrow, read our brief explaining why Trump's elections executive order is unconstitutional: www.theusconstitution.org/litigation/c...

2 weeks ago 1 2 0 0
Preview
219. Drunks, Lampposts, and the Birthright Citizenship Case Efforts to backfill academic support for the birthright citizenship executive order wouldn't have been possible without a Court open to such "scholarship."

"Academic freedom protects scholars’ right to challenge the orthodoxy; it doesn’t insulate them from charges of bad faith in doing so. But the problem here is one of both supply *and* demand. And ... #SCOTUS bears at least some responsibility for the latter."

Me in today's issue of "One First":

2 weeks ago 457 97 17 11

really like this quote from john bingham the goat on citizenship from 1867

2 weeks ago 1420 172 10 5
So why was this case brought before the Court at all? For the same reason that Cowan’s racist invocation of “yellow peril” has survived to the present day, repeated in modern form by both the president and his solicitor general. Before the Civil War, America was a white man’s government. The Reconstruction Amendments were supposed to change that, to prevent not just the existence of masters and slaves but master classes and slave classes. Trump and those around him would like to change it all back. It is hardly surprising, then, that they would revive the same arguments against birthright citizenship that the framers heard in the 1860s.

So why was this case brought before the Court at all? For the same reason that Cowan’s racist invocation of “yellow peril” has survived to the present day, repeated in modern form by both the president and his solicitor general. Before the Civil War, America was a white man’s government. The Reconstruction Amendments were supposed to change that, to prevent not just the existence of masters and slaves but master classes and slave classes. Trump and those around him would like to change it all back. It is hardly surprising, then, that they would revive the same arguments against birthright citizenship that the framers heard in the 1860s.

John Calhoun said the U.S. was a "white man's government." John Bingham, one of the authors of the 14th Amendment, said that this was a "horrid blasphemy." The birthright citizenship case is ultimately about which America we are going to be. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/0...

2 weeks ago 1489 318 15 12
Sherrilyn Ifill & ACLU lawyer Cecillia Wang hug outside the Supreme Court after Wang argued the case against Trump’s effort to end birthright citizenship

Sherrilyn Ifill & ACLU lawyer Cecillia Wang hug outside the Supreme Court after Wang argued the case against Trump’s effort to end birthright citizenship

3 kids hold red signs saying “Protect Birthright citizenship” and the 14th Amendment speaks for itself.” A crowd stands behind them in front of the Supreme Court.

3 kids hold red signs saying “Protect Birthright citizenship” and the 14th Amendment speaks for itself.” A crowd stands behind them in front of the Supreme Court.

Post image

We couldn’t have hoped for a better advocate than @aclu.org National Director Cecillia Wang today in the SCOTUS, arguing against Trump’s effort to end birthright citizenship. If there’s any fairness left, this wil be a big win for democracy, citizenship, & the integrity of the 14th Amendment.

2 weeks ago 2170 394 44 11
Preview
Most Americans Favor Birthright Citizenship. That Wasn’t Always True.

The Framers of the Fourteenth Amendment put birthright citizenship out of reach of "political whims." Read more from @elizabethwydra.bsky.social: www.nytimes.com/2026/03/31/u...

2 weeks ago 0 2 0 0
We know this isn’t true. The task ahead for the president’s opponents is to recover the egalitarian substance of the 14th Amendment and wield it against his narrow and exclusive vision of American society. This is the work of history, it is the work of law and it is the work, as always, of politics.

We know this isn’t true. The task ahead for the president’s opponents is to recover the egalitarian substance of the 14th Amendment and wield it against his narrow and exclusive vision of American society. This is the work of history, it is the work of law and it is the work, as always, of politics.

Stirring conclusion to @jamellebouie.net's column. A throughline in my study of backlash politics from Reconstruction through the civil rights movement is that backlashers sought to decenter the Declaration of Independence and the 14th Amendment as marginal, illegitimate, or misunderstood.

2 weeks ago 334 84 4 1
Preview
Opinion | The Birthright Con

“The task ahead for the president’s opponents is to recover the egalitarian substance of the 14th Amendment and wield it against his narrow and exclusive vision of American society. This is the work of history, it is the work of law and it is the work of politics.”

www.nytimes.com/2026/04/01/o...

2 weeks ago 86 26 1 1

The constitutional guarantee of birthright citizenship is clear. Learn more from @amandafrost.bsky.social's conversation with @ninatotenberg.bsky.social:

3 weeks ago 1 2 1 0
Advertisement
Preview
13th Annual Home Stretch at the Supreme Court | Constitutional Accountability Center Our panel of distinguished experts will discuss some of the most significant cases from this Supreme Court Term and look ahead to major rulings and issues on the horizon. From battles over tariffs, bi...

Registration is now open for CAC's annual Home Stretch event, featuring remarks from @elizabethwydra.bsky.social and an all-star panel of legal experts, moderated by @chrisgeidner.bsky.social. Join the conversation as we unpack the biggest issues at #SCOTUS this term:

3 weeks ago 22 11 1 0

Post-Chiles, Dobbs, and Skrmetti, states can deprive people of reproductive autonomy and youth of gender-affirming care, while simultaneously allowing medical and non-medical actors use falsehoods to deprive people of abortion or discourage them from living as themselves.

3 weeks ago 109 23 7 4