Glitch Feminism A Manifesto Legacy Russell
“Other Trans People Make Me Dysphoric”: Trans Assimilation and Cringe
When the right deploys cringe to control trans assimilation, trans people cringe at each other.
By Charlie MarkbreiterMarch 1, 2022
Awkward politices, Technologies of Popfeminist Activism, Smith-Prei and Stehle 2016
Issue 6 | January 31, 2022
Feminism and Kitsch
Becca Rothfeld
I
am the first to admit that contemporary feminism suffers from an optics problem, and I am the first to admit that an optics problem is no trivial matter. Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris Christmas ornaments, crocheted vagina hats, women at the helm of execrable tech companies urging us to “lean in” until we topple into the maw of misinformation: these are just a few of the “cringe” artifacts that feminism, in its glibbest iteration, has spawned. Believe me when I say that I take vulgarity seriously. If I did not think that aesthetic odiousness is an indication of moral rot — if I did not believe, in other words, that cringe is an ethical affront — I would probably not be a critic.
In his classic 1960 essay, “Masscult and Midcult,” the deliciously iconoclastic Dwight Macdonald complained that middlebrow cultural artifacts, with their pretense of profundity, are not innocuous. The reason we cannot just sit back and let people enjoy prestige TV and the like is that the so-called “midcult” appropriates the stylistics of difficult art, co-opting the avant-garde and masticating every provocation into a creamy pap. In other words, middlebrow muddling saps revolutionary art of its power. A similar complaint can be levied at the aesthetics of contemporary feminism: Amanda Gorman’s feel-good paean to American empire and Ruth Bader Ginsburg votive candles seamlessly assimilate the language of radicalism, thereby neutralizing it. Needless to say, both serve as alibis for the true machinery of inequality.
Letztes Cringe-Treffen vor der Sommerpause und wir kehren gedanklich dorthin zurück, wo dieses Projekt vor knapp drei Jahren seinen Ausgangspunkt hatte: Geschlecht und Geschmack, Gender Cringe, Glitch Feminism/Kitsch Feminism.