Image of facebook post explaining my thoughts about some of the critiques of the recent No Kings protests.
The text:
I have found some of the critiques online of the No Kings protests a little weird. Not because I agree with all of its framing or strategy. I particularly don't agree with its nationalist framing. But, I've also helped organize protests where I didn't agree with the framing (haha), tactics, or strategy. The point of doing the work, for me, was about taking action with a group of people I cared about to help protect others, getting more folks involved, and trying to build some momentum. The actions weren't about what I prefered, it was about what we decided was best at a time. Sometimes we got it right, sometimes we did not. And sometimes I was wrong. That's just part of organizing.
Image of my facebook post explaining some of my thoughts about critiques of the recent No Kings protests.
The text:
But, and this is what gets me about some of the criticisms (some I've seen I actually agree with), some of the best organizers and activists I've encountered also knew how to turn any gathering, from an academic talk to a national protest, into an opportunity to educate more people about the best way to escalate their tactics and to build coherent strategies, not to mention to try to convince others to come to future meetings and join their organizations. There's a reason why so many activists show up with stickers, flyers, zines, sign up sheets, etc. Yes, people remember the protest signs and some of the imagery from the protests, but some people also remember when you put something in their hands and had conversations about potential next steps.
Image of the last two paragraphs explaining my thoughts about the critiques of the recent No Kings protests.
The text:
Just telling folks that X protest is not going to work, or even making fun of folks participating, without coupling that critique with a discussion that expands folks' imaginations of what disruptive collective action and building power could look like in a fascist time just seems like a missed opportunity.
One thing I've learned through experience is there's a such thing as being completely right in an analysis, but while you might be right, you might also demobilize and discourage people. And it doesn't mean you have to cheer on every protest you disagree with. It doesn't mean big protests are beyond criticism. But it does mean finding ways to communicate a critique and illuminating a path for folks to follow.
Some of my thoughts about some of the critiques of the recent No Kings protests I've seen online: