The scandal at St Andrew's hospital should be a watershed moment for the quality of mental health inpatient care, but it's far from clear it will be.
Important intervention from @mind.org.uk CEO @drsarahhughesceo.bsky.social in @hsj.co.uk on what needs to happen next www.hsj.co.uk/patient-safe...
Posts by Tom Pollard
Important moment this morning as @mind.org.uk CEO @drsarahhughesceo.bsky.social gives evidence to the Covid-19 Inquiry on the impact of the pandemic on people with mental health problems, mental health services & the mental health of the nation. Watch from 10am here: youtube.com/@ukcovid-19i...
There are less than 5 job vacancies in rotherham for every 100 people claiming universal credit
In Pendle and Hartlepool there are around 5 job vacancies for every 100 people claiming universal credit
NEW: The government wants to boost employment among people who receive universal credit - but our analysis suggests a lack of good-quality jobs is making this near impossible. And, in some local authorities, there’s as few as 5 vacancies for every 100 people on universal credit…
Pieces like this from @drgavinfrancis.bsky.social point to a compassionate, sensitive & constructive debate we could & should be having about how we understand & respond to mental health, in contrast to the crude, boorish way 'overdiagnosis' is usually discussed www.theguardian.com/news/2026/fe...
The second part of this correction gets it wrong again - the 83% stat Milburn was referring to seems to come from 2019 research about the proportion of people showing some warning signs of poor mental health (e.g. feeling stressed, struggling with sleep) in the last year www.gov.uk/government/n...
As with the 83% 'stat', it feels like the conviction that this is just a matter of self-concept, self-efficacy & incentives is once again leading the thinking of key figures, without any firm evidence being presented of causal relationships or any real curiousity about alternative explanations
It's a shift from claiming that "everyday experiences" are being "overdiagnosed" as anxiety & depression, to saying that people do have those conditions but it's "normal" & isn't a real barrier to working
People should absolutely be supported to work where possible but this is denying their reality
Cover of the Times from today, with the top headline saying "Anxiety 'to cause a lost generation on benefits '", based on an interview with Alan Milburn
Some really unhelpful comments in this interview with Alan Milburn, particularly:
"Anxiety is normal. Depression is normal."
And the claim that 83% of the population could be diagnosed with a mental health problem at any given time
It's simply not good enough when stigma is rising again...
Job opportunity - we need a fab new colleague to do quant research on work, welfare and mental health within
@kingscsmh.bsky.social (closes 8 Feb)
This is funded until Apr/28, but we'll support you in bids to extend it - please do circulate to suitable ppl!
www.jobs.ac.uk/job/DQD294/p...
Media & political noise about "overdiagnosis" has ramped up this year, crowding out more thoughtful & constructive debate about how we should respond to rising levels of mental distress. Mind CEO @drsarahhughesceo.bsky.social points us back in the right direction here www.hsj.co.uk/mental-healt...
Stacey from @changingrealities.bsky.social has written such an honest blog about why, even with awful trolling, she won’t stop speaking up for people living in poverty
www.changingrealities.org/blog/why-i-w...
It's right to explore what's driving increased prevalence & what support people need. But as @johnharris1969.bsky.social says, in "a country in which questioning other people’s needs is almost becoming a national sport" the government risks stoking a toxic debate www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...
Surprising to see an institution with the impeccable moral integrity of FIFA toadying up to Trump
This is a welcome & reflective intervention. 'Overdiagnosis' is a simplistic & stigmatising explanation for what, in reality, is a complex interplay of health, social & economic factors. The focus should be on getting people the right support at the right time www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...
Huge moment to finally see the two-child limit scrapped. It has been a machine for driving up child poverty, which will cost us all more in the long term, scarring the lives of those directly hit by its cruel impact. Credit to everyone who has tirelessly campaigned for its end
Finally, the only way to support significant numbers of young people to overcome the barriers they face, particularly around mental health, will be to foster genuine engagement & offer genuine opportunities. Reverting to compliance & cuts again would be a huge mistake /5
This means listening to young people directly & accounting for the whole range of social, emotional & economic factors that they have experienced
There are some welcome comments on this in McFadden's Times interview, including recognition that this is an "issue of inequality" /4
One thing I've learnt from frontline practice is that if you start from a position of assuming people are trying their best in the circumstances they're facing, you're much more likely to understand how they have ended up where they are & what might help them to progress /3
First & foremost, it mustn't start with lazy pre-conceptions about young people's character, motivation & honesty
Positive to see Pat McFadden's response to the question of 'overdiagnosis': "I don't want to play amateur doctor. I want to approach this with sensitivity." /2
Any genuine attempt to better understand what is going on around young people, unemployment & poor health is welcome, especially as an alternative to rushing to propose further benefit cuts
Critical that this review gets some key things right though... 🧵
www.bbc.co.uk/news/article...
Powerful Sky News piece on the need for better support services for young people's mental health, based a new
@mind.org.uk report
Long waits for support are impacting young people's mental & physical health, as well as their education & employment news.sky.com/story/mental...
Quote from BBC News article: Mental health charity Mind's head of policy Tom Pollard said Reform's plan seemed muddled and did not appear to "bear any relation to how this benefit actually works", not least because PIP is not an out of work benefit. "People have to prove they face significant health and disability-related barriers in their day-to-day lives to qualify for Pip, and it is not based on diagnosis," he said. "Anxiety can have a debilitating impact, and many people will also have multiple and complex health issues when anxiety is recorded as their 'primary condition'."
.@mind.org.uk's response to Reform's proposals to "cut PIP payments to people with anxiety" in this BBC News
piece: bbc.co.uk/news/article...
So much of the political debate around PIP betrays a complete lack of understanding of what the benefit is for, who gets it & how it's assessed
PIP is assessed based on the impact of health problems & disabilities (often multiple & complex) on someone's ability to live independently
Saying "we'll stop PIP for people with anxiety" just bears no relation to the reality of how the benefit operates www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/10...
Coverage of @mind.org.uk's new report on youth mental health
Government plans for 50 youth hubs are welcome, but a serious response to the scale of the crisis requires services like this in every local authority, as part of a wider youth mental health strategy www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home...
Heartbreaking figures. The causes will, of course, be complex. But a caricatured debate about 'overdiagnosis' is a dangerous distraction when, as @mind.org.uk's @gemmabyrne.bsky.social says here, over half a million under-18s are on mental health waiting lists www.theguardian.com/society/2025...
Important work by @kslharrison.bsky.social of @citizensadvice.bsky.social - 'support conversations' between DWP & disabled people should about genuine engagement, not just process-driven compliance. That means being voluntary, empathic, flexible & holistic www.citizensadvice.org.uk/policy/publi...
You can find the full analysis here by Health Equity North here: committees.parliament.uk/writtenevide...
Welcome intervention, commissioned by @debbieabrahamsmp.bsky.social's Work and Pensions Select Committee, to demonstrate that better employment support for disabled people could generate significant fiscal savings, without needing to rely on crude cuts to benefits inews.co.uk/news/politic...
After many years of hard-fought progress on attitudes towards mental health, things seem to be slipping
Simplistic, often malicious, narratives about people's experiences & motivations, alongside the fallout of under-funded services, are increasing stigma www.theguardian.com/society/2025...