Doing a mixed cast for All Stars would present too many opportunities for players to play the same role they played on their original season. If the goal is maximum entertainment, I'd rather watch players go against type and navigate the game with new challenges and experiences.

Those issues would still somewhat be present no matter the type of cast, but I feel it wouldn't take away from the game as much if the players were on equal footing in terms of reputation or lack thereof.

Traitors All Stars needs a role-centric cast. Meaning all ex-Traitors or all ex-Faithfuls. Otherwise ex-Traitors cast as Faithfuls would have unfair suspicion on them due to perception or it might be obvious that they wouldn't be a Traitor again, making their Faithful game too easy. #TheTraitorsUS

Yeah you can't be the best traitor of all time if you've been clocked this clearly. Idc if you still wind up winning. Cirie was NEVER clocked. #TheTraitorsUS

Just give Rob the money. At least he'll be the first Traitor to win since Cirie if he pulls it out. That's all I got for this god awful season #TheTraitorsUS

Eric is the least Traitorous Traitor to ever Traitor #TheTraitorsUS

Can we all agree that the twists are ruining this show? #TheTraitorsUS

Welp #DragRace

a man in a red hat with the letter c on it holds a red cup ALT: a man in a red hat with the letter c on it holds a red cup

Vita gone be in tha bottom #DragRace

a drag queen with blonde hair is talking about how this turns out . ALT: a drag queen with blonde hair is talking about how this turns out .

Let's see what these Queens come up with this week #DragRace #Ad

This post being flagged as "Intolerance" 😳

Let's call a thing a thing! It's pure racism and misogyny. It's the same reason they say Danielle is the worst Traitor. These biases will always interfere with people's perception and it informs their warped justifications of it.

Don't be no hoe

I wish as a culture we would stop paying attention to MAGA(at all levels). It's been so clear that they feed on attention yet everyone is deadset on giving it to them.

Now yall can't enjoy the Queens strategizing and also be upset over Myki's placement. You cannot have it both ways #DragRace

a man with a beard is making a funny face in a bathroom . ALT: a man with a beard is making a funny face in a bathroom .

Athena WORE Jane OWTTT! #DragRace

a close up of a woman 's face with the words tayce tumblr in the lower right corner ALT: a close up of a woman 's face with the words tayce tumblr in the lower right corner

Here we go #DragRace talent show part 2!

A case that will never sit right with me

I will laugh when Dorinda gets eliminated before the finale #TheTraitorsUS

a man is taking a picture of a woman on a cell phone at a concert . ALT: a man is taking a picture of a woman on a cell phone at a concert .

This season could've been so good but now... #TheTraitorsUS

Do we know if Bomanizer has spoofed #TheTraitorsUS on tiktok? His BB video is hilarious

a woman is peeking out from behind a wall and making a face . ALT: a woman is peeking out from behind a wall and making a face .

Bye bye Colt45!!! #TheTraitorsUS

a man sitting on a couch with the words i love it on his face ALT: a man sitting on a couch with the words i love it on his face

These Queens gel so well together #DragRace #Untucked

JUICY AND MIA AAAATTTTTEEEDOWNN!! #DragRace

Also I think they should forego the talent show completely if they aren't doing it for the premiere #DragRace

Part of me feels like Rate-A-Queen should be an AllStars twist. #DragRace

Jane has been killing me with the general state of confusion she's been in this whole episode 😂 #DragRace

I know for a fact these talent shows would be way more entertaining if they gave the Queens more time for each number #DragRace

Zara Larsson being that gworl as per usual #DragRace

Omg "Nini you could leave!" "Not Nini, go home!" 🤣🤣🤣 #DragRace