This thread was mostly an exercise for myself to step back from a report a few days after it came out and to try get more consistent with Bluesky posting, but if anyone's made it this far the full report is here: doi.org/10.26504/rs207
14/14
Some take-homes are:
(1) there's no evidence for an urban-rural divide
(2) the public lack clear guidance on dietary emissions
(3) farmers are broadly onboard but could do with support
(4) a small climate 'resistant' group may drive misperceptions if given disproportionate airtime
13/14
It may instead be driven by a small subgroup who appear resistant to policies and report very low levels of concern about climate change. But we find evidence for people with these views in rural and urban communities too.
12/14
So, given all of this evidence, why might there be a perception that farmers are anti-climate action?
(Some) farmers are indeed less likely to recognise the climate impact of eating meat and are less supportive of restrictive farming policies - but the differences are pretty small.
11/14
So farmers are broadly concerned and supportive of some forms of climate action. Why don't we see more climate-friendly farming practices?
We find considerable scope for improving farmer awareness of these practices, some of which may be easy wins:
10/14
Across a range of climate policies, we also see broadly similar levels of support across the three groups.
(There are some differences for specific policies, with farmers less supportive of reducing the national herd than the public (2.2 vs. 3.5-3.8), but little difference on most).
9/14
Which may be partly driven by the public underestimating how worried farmers are about climate change.
8/14
Almost half of farmers even cite climate change as one of the top issues they face (not sig different to the proportion who cite excessive regulation!)
The public also underestimate how many farmers struggle with negative perceptions of farming.
7/14
When it comes to concern, the distribution of worry in all groups is broadly similar. Though it looks like there may be fewer farmers at the 'extremely worried' end, the differences aren't even close to statistically significant (ps > .78).
(Note the distribution uptick at 1 though!)
6/14
Farmers do substantially worse on the plant-based item, and we have some evidence that this is a form of motivated reasoning -> the difference is driven by beef and dairy farmers.
But it's also worth noting that majorities of all groups are poor on dietary emissions.
5/14
Where we do find a difference is on understanding of what individual actions matter.
Farmers do slightly worse than the public (but again, if anything, the rural-urban divide favours rural).
4/14
We also find no difference in their understanding of what sectors are most responsible for emissions (with no improvement from when we first measured this 3 years ago.)
Concerningly, 1 in 3 farmers and the same proportion of the public don't identify agriculture as one of the big emitters
3/14
We find no reliable differences in knowledge of the effects of climate change between rural residents, urban residents and farmers. (If anything, rural respondents did slightly better!) 2/14
Rural communities & especially farmers are often painted as anti-climate action.
This week, we published a report to provide some evidence on this.
The results, based on a survey of the public (n=1200) and almost 500 farmers (recruited at events, door-to-door, etc), are pretty interesting:
🧵
Today, we have published the report 'Perceptions of Climate Change and Policy Among Farmers and the Public in Ireland'.
💡 Read the key findings: www.esri.ie/news/farmers...
📄 Download the full report: www.esri.ie/publications...
🤩🤩 Paper finally out in the AER!
With my co-authors (incl. @bluebery-planterose.com & @s-stantcheva.bsky.social) we surveyed climate attitudes in 20 countries covering 72% of global emissions.
In brief, people want ambitious, global, and fair climate policies. A 🧵⬇️
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=...
Today, we have published 'The Response of Low-Income Households to the Cost-of-Living Crisis in Ireland'.
💡 Read the key findings: www.esri.ie/news/low-inc...
📄 Download the full report: www.esri.ie/publications...
Today, @ESRI.ie, the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth (DCEDIY), and @deptjusticeirl.bsky.social have published the Monitoring Report on Integration 2024.
💡 Read the key findings: www.esri.ie/news/migrant...
📄 Download the full report: www.esri.ie/publications...
Today, we have published 'Promoting a nationwide collective response: lessons from the social activity measure during the COVID-19 pandemic.'
💡 Read the Research Bulletin: esri.ie/publications...
📄 Download the full report: esri.ie/publications...
Paid internship for final year undergrad/masters students to work on an exciting environmental policy project
@isweconomics.bsky.social - if you haven’t already come across this!
NEW REPORT: New ESRI research finds high levels of prejudice against Travellers and Roma in Ireland
Today, we publish 'Understanding Attitudes to Travellers and Roma in Ireland'
💡 Read more: www.esri.ie/news/new-esri-research-f...
📄 www.esri.ie/publications/understandi...
RESEARCH BULLETIN How to Encourage Collective Climate Action
Today, we have published a new Research Bulletin titled 'How to Encourage Collective Climate Action' by Lucie Martin, @shanetimmons.bsky.social , and Pete Lunn.
📄 Download the full research bulletin: www.esri.ie/publications/how-to-enco...
Great to showcase the breadth and quality of behavioural research in Ireland at this year’s Econ, Psych & Policy conference @esri.ie - already looking forward to next year!
🌱 Our latest JRC Science for Policy Report! 🌱
"Setting the Scene for Harmonised Waste-Sorting Labels in the European Union" outlines key insights to guide EU-wide waste-sorting labels. 🌍♻️
publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/h...
👇 Key findings:
And there are some things we have evidence no evidence on: what happens when different groups of people are asked to change in different ways to reach the same goal (e.g. less car use in urban areas and less fossil fuel burning in rural ones).
As usual - more research needed! 9/9
- The consequences will be most strongly felt by future generations
- We have an inherent bias toward maintaining the status quo, even when change is beneficial 8/9
But climate change comes with unique challenges:
- The problem is "multi-level" - behaviour needs to change at the local level for goals that are set nationally or internationally
- People are often uncertain about what actions make a difference 7/9
We see these mattering not just in the scientific papers but in Irish towns too - the Killarney Coffee Cup Project is a great example and one we highlight in the report. 6/9
