#Peerreviewquality

"Another key point of this research is the identification of eight quality characteristics for review texts: constructive/helpful, specific, fair, thorough/comprehensive, readability/organization/clarity, tone, objectivity, and consistency" #Peerreviewquality

Defining quality in peer review reports: a scoping review - Knowledge and Information Systems This study examines the challenge of defining quality in peer-review reports, a crucial yet underexplored aspect of academic publishing. Reviewers are vital gatekeepers of scientific knowledge, but un...

A new and insightful systematic review on #peerreviewquality that is a wealth of tips, best practices, guidelines, and instructions:
link.springer.com/article/10.1...