A Wakelet compilation of #4DWorkshop tweets is now at http://bit.ly/2JpetRM . If you don't see your tweet, let me know and I'd be happy to add it. Thanks for an amazing 2.5 days!

Periodic table of elements for *geobiologists* poses @d_giovannelli with appropriate annotations? #4dworkshop

Reproducible visualization in a Jupyter notebook with Jupyter widgets of gene regulatory network transcriptional model and experimental data. How well did stats for deriving transcriptional regulatory networks work? Can create github repo w/Binder notebook to share #4dworkshop

Loved the software demo of the prototype PHINCH, http://PHINCH.org http://phinch.org/blog/ by @hollybik as a framework for visualizing bio data, and seeking more data, as well as a to geographically map it! #4DWorkshop

Can we construct the global geologic rock record & map in 4D similarly to a map of the stars? (aka Macrostrat and linked to GeoDeepDive + ROCKD + data on facies, clastics, bioturbation through time, etc.) #4dworkshop

And by the way, stop calling it “small data,” but rather say “handcrafted artismal/artisanal data” 😉 #4dworkshop

Very refreshing topic that, speaking only for myself, I don’t see often enough: adapting big data techniques to address small data needs (related to Digital Humanities, Qualitative Social Sciences) #4dworkshop cc @steinbergspace

Love this theme on needed cultural changes as summarized by @louisekellogg and decorated with the “iconic” Tufte visualization of Napoleon’s march! #4dworkshop

Once more with feeling: the easiest tool is not always the right tool. Once more with feeling: we need to be citing *software* and with the DOI for the code itself!! (See https://geodynamics.org/cig/ #4dworkshop

I really enjoyed being in this breakout on analytical & visualization methods as led by @louisekellogg of @ucdavis + Linda Gunderson of @USGS #4dworkshop

Impediments to making progress in visualization Earth/Space/Life sciences summary by @ESIP_Erin . Also G-Plates and many other resources to be added to a Google doc that some of us are compiling (thx again @chrismentzel) #4dworkshop

There was finally a mention of 3D printing! 😉 Continued breakout group summary by @ESIP_Erin #4dworkshop

Critical needs/opportunities in visualizing complex environment in Earth/space/life sciences. Visualizations as a “bridging object” including Iterations along the way very productive, while advancing the viz field itself as nicely summarized by @ESIP_Erin #4dworkshop

Needs + general opportunities in deep learning: including general machine learning (where we define features of interest) and deep learning (where the machine defines). Helpful for #Esri GeoAI initiative too #4DWorkshop cc @Microsoft_Green @lucasjoppa @david_gadsden

Opportunities in deep learning (and brainstorming about a possible 4th law of thermodynamics) as summarized by @Kristin_Tolle (co-editor of the landmark book on the 4th Paradigm 😉) from that breakout at #4DWorkshop

Our overarching mission for the #4dworkshop

Perhaps great disciplinary cross-fertilization will come out of #4dworkshop as in prior @deepcarb workshops that spawned at Deep Earth Water Community

Livestream archive and PowerPoints from #4dworkshop breakout groups are now online at http://4d-workshop.net

The grand challenge continues, as expressed by the geoscience/bioscience/planetary science community here at http://4d-workshop.net #4DWorkshop What say ye @A_C_Robinson @UCGIScience @CartographyGIS @mapsOverlord

Current challenges in visualization of Earth system science data #4dworkshop breakout cc @NathanCShephard @williamscraigm @EvanSinar @_ChrisJAndrews @kennethfield @cartatesri

“The highest cited papers often included the most figures” as quoted from a Nature study by #4dworkshop visualization breakout. So true in my experience as I was taught in grad school to ingest, understand, and interpret papers by 1st explaining the figures in lab mtgs

Why visualization is so important in Earth disciplines as presented by co-chair @Leinen4ocean . Investment *into it* will drive results *out of it* #4dworkshop breakout

A crazy idea that would be so cool and useful if one day implemented! #4dworkshop

And now for computing resources in microbial biology, environments, and protein expression #4DWorkshop

Burning questions on the origin of life and related database needs #4dworkshop

What are the critical needs and opportunities in linking geochemistry, astrobiology and the origins of life? What is life? What are the minimal requirements that would fit into an operational definition of life, at least? #4DWorkshop

Challenging in that we don’t really have a rock record for the bio, but we DO have registries of registries! 😉 #4dworkshop

Rather than just a geo problem or a bio problem, we are really dealing with an Earth System Science challenge, notes the eminent Paul Falkowski of @RutgersU in summarizing the co-evolution in geosphere and biosphere breakouts #4dworkshop

4D Workshop Unveiling Earth's Evolution through Data-Driven Discovery Across Deep Time

Was away on break & not live tweeting, but really enjoyed from hallway the absolutely stellar talk by Timothy Lyons of @UCRiverside on linking geochemistry (esp oxygenesis) in deep time.... Try to catch it in full on http://4d-workshop.net if you missed live stream #4dworkshop

A jungle of data formats, as well as repositories (e.g., Pangea, @datadryad, @BCODMO, @iedadata etc., but @d_giovannelli rightly calls for better, clearer rules of engagement. But we continue to evolve and mature! #4dworkshop