1. Broken Promises and Fiscal Mismanagement
Plante's early tenure was marred by a high-profile reversal on taxes, eroding public trust. Her 2017 campaign pledged no tax hikes beyond inflation (around 2.1%), but her first budget delivered a 3.3% increase, including a sharp rise in water taxes to address a $358 million deficit inherited from the previous administration. Critics, including opposition leader Aref Salem, accused her of misleading voters and prioritizing ideology over transparency.
2. Urban Mobility and "War on Cars" Backlash
Plante's push for a "bike-friendly" city—adding over 1,000 km of paths and pedestrian zones—was hailed by environmentalists but lambasted as an "anti-car" crusade that ignored commuters and businesses. Projects like the controversial closure of Camilien-Houde Way on Mount Royal (despite a 2019 public consultation recommending against it) cost nearly $100 million and sparked outrage for prioritizing ideology over accessibility.
3. Homelessness, Public Safety, and Social Services Failures
Under Plante, visible homelessness surged post-COVID, with encampments, garbage-strewn streets, and opioid crises overwhelming neighborhoods. Critics pointed to inadequate responses, including poor snow removal (icy sidewalks in 2017–2018) and a spike in antisemitic incidents (e.g., firebombings of synagogues like Beth Tikvah in 2024, amid unchecked protests blocking streets).
4. Scandals and Ethical Lapses
Plante's administration was rocked by ethical controversies, amplifying perceptions of entitlement. Dominique Ollivier, her executive committee president, resigned in 2023 after spending $18,000+ in public funds on lavish meals and wine at the Office de consultation publique de Montréal—echoing Plante's own criticized Vienna wine-tasting trip.
Plante restricted social media comments in 2024 to curb abuse but faced accusations of stifling dissent, with opposition calling it "unethical" and anti-democratic.
Yes, soon to be former #Montréal mayor #ValériePlante "didn’t do enough" for the #homeless & not only "spent too much on cops", but condoned #SPVM #PoliceViolence & other #AbuseOfPower.
Anyone who believes #ValPlante didn't embarrass #Montrealers is UNinformed or delusional.
#PolMTL #PolQC #PolCan