#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "evolution takes pressure and time - selective pressure coming from funders right now, frustrated researchers, institutions (slower/conservative) #helios, societal context (distrust in science/institutions)" #openaccess #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "the literature we produce right now is already being fed into LLMs so it's more important than ever that we get a handle on incentive misalignment. Opening #peerreview is an important trust signal to add into this work." #openscience #preprints #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "publications are becoming an advertisement for the research rather than vehicle for actually communicating the science. #openaccess #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social now digital publishing confronting bad incentives: clicks, revenue per article, fraud, assessment paradigms. Journals are trying to take on the role of preventing consequences of these misaligned incentives, driving up cost. #openaccess #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social for centuries, publishers have been doing heavy lifting (managing #peerreview and producing/distributing physical objects). Science was simpler, everything could fit on flat page. but 21st century data is bigger/more complicated than ever. #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social unit of dissem evolution: @eLife, @curvenote journals, @theAGU piloting #notebooks now w/ #jupyternotebooks, @NeuroLibre @DeSciLabs #preprints where narrative/data/outputs are linked #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "when narrative is more closely connected to data, it deepen #peerreview. Reviewers would do this as a default bc of the data adjacency to the #preprint." #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "if #preprints are written as extension of data, they're the best outputs we can hope for esp from #researchintegrity standpoint. Not impossible to fabricate an entire lab notebook but much harder. Trust signals are more deeply embedded." #openscience
Kicking off @scholarlypub.bsky.social's New Directions in Scholarly Publishing with a keynote by @ madubs.bsky.social, Director, Open Science Strategy, at @hhmi.bsky.social.
@heatherstaines.bsky.social and Zsolt Silberer are attending, so please be sure to say hello!
#SSPND24 #ScholComm
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "reproducibility should be embedded and upfront in the research, not an afterthought." @curvenote enabling interactive visuals for HHMI researchers pulling directly from #jupyternotebook #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "reproducibility should be embedded and upfront in the research, not an afterthought." @curvenote enabling interactive visuals for HHMI researchers. #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "show rather than tell" means a "meaningful exploration of the data itself." NYTimes/WaPo immersive articles did this - esp during COVID - allowed data interrogation in an accessible way. #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social featuring @curvenote platform to demonstrate what a truly embedded process looks like -- all functions well within our capacity right now. Not fancy but makes paper reading less laborious. #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social reliable research needs to be accessible, actionable, and complete to achieve ideal outcomes - FAIR, versional, shows rather than tells, data adjacent, doesn't put supplementary info in the corner #openscience #openaccess
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social research paper itself hasn't kept pace with changes in the lab - we can't maximally capitalize on science if we can't communicate it. Not just about eliminating PDF - we need to communicate the entire discovery process #openaccess #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social "the doing of science HAS evolved." #biomedical context --> labs using robotics, sophisticated machines to handle machines - faster, precise, consistent, #smartconsumables (vials w/ barcodes etc), Smart instruments, #ELNs (electronic lab notebooks)
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social PRC doesn't throw out #peerreview but frames it in a more realistic light: valuable discourse that's transparent. "What I love most is that it elevates peer review. Demands a different level of accountability. Reviews can be credited" #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social - #publishreviewcurate critiques come re: #peerreview - Pointing to www.experimental-history.com/p/the-rise-a... #openaccess #openscience
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social - pressures abound for dissemination sys to change. HHMI leadership proposed Published, Review, Curate (PRC) #publishreviewcurate - author is always in control of when paper is made available; #peerreview are public and various forms of curation happen later
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social - hard to argue that #openaccess is not a good thing BUT publishing digitally is MORE expensive and authors/libraries bearing the brunt of cost; APCs are exclusionary; article economy is a nightmare
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social - hard to argue that #openaccess is not a good thing - seismic shift to authors retaining copyright and being apply to licenses that give them control #CCBY #rightsretention
#SSPND24 @maw_tweets 3 major transformation since internet: incredible infrastructure to index/organize/dissem/structure articles - opening a lot of possibilities #openscience #peerreview Also 2. #openaccess 3. #preprints
#SSPND24 @madubs.bsky.social private drafts confidentially sent to articles, reviewed confidentially and months/years later decision is made - black box as to how decision was made. Pub released w/ stamp of credibility. Review curate model. (RCM) #openscience #peerreview
@madubs.bsky.social #SSPND24 keynoting: the scholarly article has hardly changed (we took a picture and added formatting :) and HOW we communicate research hasn't changed - emerging traits: system of dissemination and UNIT of dissemination
