Letter. Header: In the Name of the Old Ones Miskatonic Literary Circle. Dirk W. Mosig, December 21st, 1975
Dear Prof. Taylor:
Thank you for your kind letter of December 19th.
I was myself quite sold, initially, to the autobiographical interpretation of The Outsider, but later research makes me dout that HPL's childhood was nearly as miserable as my sketch suggests....There is little doubt that some autobiographical elements entered in the composition of several of Lovecraft's tales (The Outsider, The Silver Key, The Thing at the Doorstep, &c) but I doubt that any one tale can be reduced to strict autobiography....
Yes, indeed, Jung is anything but parsimonious.... But then, Freud's hypothetical constructs are also objectionable on the same grounds. The only psychological theory completely devoid of hypothetical constructs and intervening variables is Skinnerian behaviorism....Although I generally agree with Skinner's conclusions about the determination of behavior by the contingencies of reinforcement, a literary analysis in terms of operant conditioning theory would be, I fear, rather dull. My own favorite interpretation of THE OUTSIDER is the rationalistic one. After reading my little paper, Frank Belknap Long wrote that he felt confident that, had HPL lived to read the thing, he would have initialled the mechanistic-materialistic elucidation.... I am less confident of this than Belknapius, but it does fit with HPL's Weltansicht. I am particularly interested in HPL's philosophical thinking, not only because it parallels my own, but because I feel that his cosmic-minded rationalism provides the key for the appreciation of his memorable tales. George Wetzel made some suggestions on this line years ago, as did Matthew Onderdonk in the FRESCO Symposium. A few days ago I had the pleasure of reading a couple of MA theses (Svartz 1972, Brown U., Lynn, 1970, U. df R.I.) which also pointed out the significance of Loveeraft's materialistic-phi1osophy for the interpretatio…
SUPERNATURAL HORROR IN LITERATURE is now available as an inexpensive Dover reprint ($1.50), and would be ideal for a course in weird fiction, indeed. Let me know if your proposed course materializes. The WHISPERS papers are minor, one a Jungian analysis (sketchy and superficial) of a series of HPL's tales -- I was inspired to write this one by Prof. Barton St. Armand, whose forthcoming book from Mirage should be most interesting. The other should be out this month, and is a brief essay on HPL's prediction of "future shock" and a new dark age....
Digressing, Freud did make a good point when he called religion "the obsessive neurosis of mankind...." Jung, on the other hand, was involved in too much mysticism to be truly scientific. Nevertheless, it is curious to observe that both theories have received some borderline support from modern neurophysiological and ethological research. The modern "tri-unit" theory of the brain (metabolic functions & basic drives mediated by the "reptilian brain" -hindbrain plus midbrain plus diencophalon; inhibition of previous learning made possible by the limbic system; and planning & "higher" functions, like reasoning, involving the neocortex) shows an uncomfortable resemblance to the old trichotomy of id-superego-ego.... Ethological evidence as to the inheritance of fixed action patterns (such as that resulting from the research of Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen -the recent Nobel prize laureates-, Eibl-Eibesfeldt, and others) make the Jungian conception of the archetype less ludicrous. However, that is a long way from saying that either theory has been significantly validated. Jung's theory seems to be slightly more elegant, when applied to HPL's tales than Freud's libidinal approach, but neither should be taken seriously....
Back to another subject, I have been wondering for some time whether the academic community may be ready to lend at least some support to a Lovecraftian Journal) perhaps titled LOVECRAFT STUDIES, and patterned a…
One of our emeritus faculty members, Yozan (Dirk) Mosig, was an influential figure in Lovecraft studies. We acquired a letter archive from one of his correspondents. This wideranging letter, from Mosig to Taylor, debates various aspects of H.P. Lovecraft's thought. #UnusualArchives #Archive30