Advertisement · 728 × 90
#
Hashtag
#chardet
Advertisement · 728 × 90
The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft Copyleft gave us the right to be free; AI gives us the power to be free. The scarcity of programming knowledge is evaporating, turning the “freedom to fork” from a legal theory into a functional reality for every user.

The first liberation gave us the code; the second liberation gives us the mastery of it. www.maffulli.net/2026/03/16/ai-final-fron... #ai #chardet #copyleft #gpl #OpenSource #SoftwareFreedom

2 0 0 0
The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft Copyleft gave us the right to be free; AI gives us the power to be free. The scarcity of programming knowledge is evaporating, turning the “freedom to fork” from a legal theory into a functional reality for every user.

The fundamental goal of the Free Software movement was individual agency over the machine. www.maffulli.net/2026/03/16/ai-final-fron... #ai #chardet #copyleft #gpl #OpenSource #SoftwareFreedom

1 0 0 0
Preview
What does the MIT license cover in chardet? · Issue #334 · chardet/chardet In #327 @dan-blanchard says: I did not write the code by hand, but I was deeply involved in designing, reviewing, and iterating on every aspect of it. [ . . . ] But the evidence here is clear: 7.0 ...

The whole #chardet drama is such a shitshow!
Not only did Dan Blanchard changed the license from MIT to a BSD Zero Clause license but also closed the issue of FOSS lawyer Richard Fontana himself as well as locked both remaining open issues regarding the changed license. /1
github.com/chardet/char...

3 1 1 0
The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft Copyleft gave us the right to be free; AI gives us the power to be free. The scarcity of programming knowledge is evaporating, turning the “freedom to fork” from a legal theory into a functional reality for every user.

The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft www.maffulli.net/2026/03/16/ai-final-fron... #ai #chardet #copyleft #gpl #OpenSource #SoftwareFreedom

0 0 0 0
The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft Copyleft gave us the right to be free; AI gives us the power to be free. The scarcity of programming knowledge is evaporating, turning the “freedom to fork” from a legal theory into a functional reality for every user.

The “freedom to fork” was a theoretical right that required thousands of dollars in labor or years of study to exercise. AI code assistants are collapsing that cost www.maffulli.net/2026/03/16/ai-final-fron... #ai #chardet

0 0 0 0
The second liberation: AI is the final frontier of Copyleft Copyleft gave us the right to be free; AI gives us the power to be free. The scarcity of programming knowledge is evaporating, turning the “freedom to fork” from a legal theory into a functional reality for every user.

If the GNU GPL was the legal hack for freedom, AI is the technical one www.maffulli.net/2026/03/16/ai-final-fron... #ai #chardet #copyleft #gpl #OpenSource #SoftwareFreedom

0 0 0 0

Chardet 7.0 : X48 En Perf, Licence MIT Contestée
pausehardware.com/chardet-7-perfs-ia-licen...

❝Le #mainteneur de #chardet a publié la version 7.0 d’un des détecteurs d’#encodage les plus utilisés de l’#écosystème

https://seenthis.net/messages/1162839

0 0 0 0

AI can rewrite open source code—but can it rewrite the license, too?

arstechnica.com/ai/2026/03/ai-can-rewrit...

#AI #Programming #OpenSource #Chardet

2 0 1 0
Original post on mastodon.faithtree.social

“Two esoteric programming events bubbled up this past week. If you’re not into #computerScience, they may appear irrelevant to you. They’re not. The arcane managed to bring to life our pressing questions about whether #AI can create or is a regurgitation machine.” https://reviews.ofb.biz/sa1401 […]

2 0 0 0

AI can rewrite open source code—but can it rewrite the license, too? https://arstechni.ca #MarkPilgrim #ClaudeCode #chardet #AI

0 0 0 0
Original post on mastodon.faithtree.social

Two #AI-related events over the past week — the #Chardet licensing controversy and legendary computer scientist #DonKnuth's shock over AI helping discover a theorem for a problem he'd not yet solved — demand a reckoning: precisely how creative is AI? https://reviews.ofb.biz/sa1401

#Creativity […]

1 1 0 0
Post image

AI can rewrite open source code—but can it rewrite the license, too? Is it clean "reverse engineering" or just an LLM-filtered "derivative work"? Original Source Is it clean "...

#AI #chardet #Claude #Code #Mark #Pilgrim

Origin | Interest | Match

2 0 0 0
Post image

AI can rewrite open source code—but can it rewrite the license, too? Is it clean "reverse engineering" or just an LLM-filtered "derivative work"? Computer engineers and programmer...

#AI #chardet #Claude #Code #Mark #Pilgrim

Origin | Interest | Match

1 0 0 0
Original post on mastodon.tmm.cx

There is a silver lining to the whole #python #chardet debacle. If it is legal to throw a pile of code at an LLM, and tell it to write a new version of that code that is not a derivative then that gives us a lot of options too.

GPL compatible #ZFS? no problem! #ReactOS from the leaked NT/2k […]

3 1 0 0
Preview
Chardet : quand une IA réécrit un logiciel open source en cinq jours et change sa licence - Korben Le développeur Dan Blanchard a utilisé Claude d'Anthropic pour réécrire intégralement chardet, une bibliothèque Python téléchargée 130 millions de fois par ...

#Chardet : quand une #IA réécrit un logiciel #opensource #foss en cinq jours et change sa #licence , sans vergogne de #LGPL à #MIT ...
Vide #juridique total...

korben.info/chardet-quan...

1 0 0 0
Original post on mas.to

Can an AI rewrite of a software package be relicensed? It's complex, AND simple.

It may be impossible to prove it's not a derivative work, hence un-relicensable.

However, separately (US) Supreme Court upheld decision that machine generated code does not have copyright. Thus it also can not be […]

1 1 1 0

Holy crap, this commit
github.com/chardet/chardet/commit/7...

0 0 0 0
Can coding agents relicense open source through a “clean room” implementation of code? Over the past few months it’s become clear that coding agents are extraordinarily good at building a weird version of a “clean room” implementation of code. The most famous version …

Can coding agents relicense open source through a “clean room” implementation of code?

https://simonwillison.net/2026/Mar/5/chardet/

#AI #Programming #OpenSource #Chardet

1 1 1 0
Preview
无权重新授权本项目 No right to relicense this project (github.com) 03-05  ↑ 114 HN Points

Mark Pilgrim weighs in on the #chardet relicensing
https://github.com/chardet/chardet/issues/327

0 0 0 0