Grosse Pointe viewers intrigued by NBC’s 'Grosse Pointe Garden Society'
A new NBC dramedy has piqued the curiosity of folks in Grosse Pointe, whose Detroit-adjacent community is the setting of a fictional murder mystery.
“Grosse Pointe Garden Society” depicts four garden club members, Birdie (Melissa Fumero), Catherine (Aja Naomi King), Brett (Ben Rappaport), and Alice (AnnaSophia Robb), at the center of the murder. The show airs at 10 p.m. Sundays on NBC and streams on Peacock the next day.
Reactions to the show were mixed.
“The way the women stick together, the garden club sticks together, that is a very Grosse Pointe thing because people are very loyal to each other,” says Colleen Fitzgerald, 56, who has lived in Grosse Pointe Farms since 2004 with her son Jimmy, 23, a recent Michigan State University graduate.
“If you have a friend group, whether it's soccer moms or choir moms or baseball moms, it is a group that really sticks together. I mean, we do tend to be very cliquey,” she said.
Jimmy says of the Atlanta-shot show, “With the scenes that you can vaguely see that they’re going for the Village but it’s not the Village — but they obviously went to Grosse Pointe and they know Grosse Pointe and they’re trying to recreate that — that’s just going to feel not real to me because I grew up here and I know all the locations that they’re trying to replicate.”
Teddy Sweeney, 24, grew up in Grosse Pointe Farms, graduated from the University of Michigan, and currently lives in Detroit, but still comes to Grosse Pointe regularly.
“I love the little callouts,” Sweeney said. A line about the Junior League, a nonprofit group of women volunteers, made him laugh. “The thing that kept sticking out to me was how there's a path, (and) there's an expectation,” says Sweeney, as he sees on the show a mother who is determined to have her high schooler get accepted to the University of Michigan. The parent doesn’t think her son should be penalized for plagiarizing an assignment.
Dominic Bennett thinks “the show reinforces that there's really two different Grosse Pointes.” He says he and his spouse, Marisa, “snuck in here 12 years ago at the bottom of the real estate market, and we're house-poor.” Then there’s “the wealthy Grosse Pointe … which I think is being depicted here (on the show),” Dominic says.
You may hear a local refer to Grosse Pointe as “the bubble.” Teddy Sweeney sheds light on this. “I think the bubble is from the fact that we, especially as kids (who) grow up in this environment, we're not thinking about anything else except for, what am I going to do today, and what are my parents telling me to do today, basically.”
Sweeney adds, “You don't have to worry about the fact that, like, two, three miles away are abandoned homes and entire blocks of blight and real-world problems that people have to deal with.”
While Sweeney is glad to see main characters of color on “Grosse Pointe Garden Society,” he keeps in mind real acts of racism that have happened in the community, including teenagers using racial slurs and a Grosse Pointe Park resident displaying a KKK flag.
Some other problems pale in comparison to such racism and hatred, but alcohol culture and infidelity — the latter being more overt on TV than it is on the surface in the community was also mentioned.
Several locals who watched “Grosse Pointe Garden Society” feel that the series could have been set in any affluent area of the country. They mention that B-roll or establishing shots of the real Grosse Pointe (especially Lakeshore Drive) would make a difference.
“I want Grosse Pointe to be more of a character in the show,” says Jimmy Fitzgerald.
Of course, “Grosse Pointe” is only half of the show’s title. The garden society is a social circle for all four main characters, and it’s where the mysterious murder unfolds.
The real nonprofit Grosse Pointe Garden Center is not commenting publicly on “Grosse Pointe Garden Society” at this time, but its members often shop at Allemon’s Landscape Center on Mack Avenue.
Joe Allemon’s grandfather acquired the land in 1910 and started the business in 1929. Five generations of Allemons’ names are painted on the side of the building.
Joe Allemon has not watched the series yet, but he hears about “Grosse Pointe Garden Society” from customers and has spotted the show’s “Mack Avenue Garden Center” in a clip.
“That was neat to see that,” Joe says from behind the register, noting the store’s 115-year history. “And we’re just a little pickle-barrel operation anyways, so it’s kind of a nice fit, I thought.”
He describes customers affiliated with the real garden center as “knowledgeable,” “intelligent,” welcoming, giving and “no pun intended, but very down to earth.”
“This is my 52nd year, and they will tell me things that I haven't learned, that I don't know,” Joe says. An example? One gardener won’t kill her weeds with chemicals. She smothers them, instead, with materials including newspaper, cardboard, mulch and water.
Employee Sam Carroll has worked at Allemon’s for five months and currently lives in Detroit. Carroll chatted while adjusting a yellow sign outside that counted down to spring. He recalls this past autumn when local gardeners needed mums.
“If the colors don't quite match up between one and the other, then they're not gonna buy it, because they need to have two on each side, and it's got to be even,” he said. “It is, in a weird way, almost like a symmetrical level of thinking. It's like everything has to be just so, just right. Like a postcard.”
While exclusive garden clubs do exist, the Grosse Pointe Garden Center is open to anyone and costs $20 to join. The center maintains multiple gardens located at the Grosse Pointe War Memorial, and distinguished speakers share their gardening knowledge at member events. Some members of the Grosse Pointe Garden Center are also involved in gardening projects in Detroit, like the Oudolf Garden on Belle Isle. And yes, there is a competition each year between eight local garden clubs; this takes place in the Trial Gardens created by the late Eleanor Roche, landscape architect.
The gardening world of Michigan is huge, with numerous gardening organizations in Grosse Pointe alone. Some members of the Grosse Pointe Garden Center also complete the rigorous training of the MSU Extension Master Gardener Program.
One thing the real Grosse Pointe has in common with the new TV series is the wonder of a garden bringing so many different folks together.
Marisa Bennett grew up in Sterling Heights and says, “I would have thought everybody was this preppy, belonged-to-some-sort-of-private-club person. I never would have thought that there were people like us that lived in this community.” Both she and Dominic appreciate the neighborliness they have found in Grosse Pointe.
“We're a very multigenerational community and their cast isn't reflective of that yet,” Marisa says. “You don't have the old person who just knows everything that's going on, (who) has the opinion.”
Though differences in the appearance of fictional Grosse Pointe and real Grosse Pointe (like the height of buildings or newness in the scenery) stand out to her, Marisa plans to watch the next episode of “Grosse Pointe Garden Society.” Dominic thinks the third episode is the best yet. He bluntly states, “This show is like bad beer. The more you have, the better they get.”
Multiple moments from the third episode elicit laughs from the Fitzgeralds. Colleen finds the show “very well-written,” and Jimmy compliments the acting.
Colleen concludes, “I think that I likely wouldn’t be watching it if it wasn’t called ‘Grosse Pointe Garden Society.’ That drew me in. But I liked it as a show, regardless of the name.” She never missed an episode of “Desperate Housewives” and liked learning that co-creator Jenna Bans had also written for that show.
There’s more than meets the eye in an intricate garden, and Grosse Pointe has its layers, too.
'Grosse Pointe Garden Society'
10 p.m. Sundays on NBC, streams the next day on Peacock
This article originally appeared on The Detroit News: Grosse Pointe viewers intrigued by NBC’s 'Grosse Pointe Garden Society'
A new NBC dramedy has piqued the curiosity of folks in Grosse Pointe, whose Detroit-adjacent community is the setting of a fictional murder mystery.
“Grosse Pointe Garden Society” depicts four garden club members, Birdie (Melissa Fumero), Catherine (Aja Naomi… #GrossePointe #GardenSociety #NBC